Last updated:

BMA responds to Government public consultation on patient data security reviews

In response to the Government's response to the public consultation on National Data Guardian for Health and Care’s (NDG) and Care Quality Commission’s (CQC) data security reviews,  Dr John Chisholm, BMA medical ethics committee chair, said: 

“The Government’s response to the public consultation on the data security and opt-out model reviews by the National Data Guardian and Care Quality Commission includes a welcome focus on cybersecurity and cyber-resilience, and on the implementation of more suitable data security standards. There are many potential benefits in sharing data for medical research and improving clinical care. 

“However, doctors have serious concerns about the removal of patients’ right to opt out of having their details sent from their GP surgery to NHS Digital, without first putting in place the necessary protections and guarantees about how this information will be used.

“The current arrangement between NHS Digital and the Home Office, in which the Home Office can request confidential patient information for immigration purposes, is undermining patient trust in how their confidential information is used. 

“This arrangement between the Home Office and NHS Digital adopts a lower ‘public interest’ threshold for sharing confidential data than is expected by the General Medical Council. 

“Patients deserve to know how and under what circumstances their personal data may be used. The BMA believes there needs to be a higher threshold for releasing information from NHS Digital to the Home Office, and independent oversight of disclosures before the removal of the opt-out. 

“If patients don’t have confidence in the system, not only does it damage the doctor patient relationship, there is also a real risk that some will be put off visiting their GP, which could have serious public health implications.

“We are currently in ongoing constructive discussions with the government and hope we can reach an agreement that is in the best interests of patients.” 


Notes to Editors


For further information please contact:

British Medical Association, BMA House, Tavistock Square, London, WC1H 9JP
Telephone: 020 7383 6448 
Email: [email protected]
Media centre | Twitter | Youtube - BMA TV | Flickr